Trust the loop.
Keep the question open.
A proposal is a beginning. Let a builder act, a reviewer disagree, and reality answer back. You decide when the evidence is enough.
Intent
Revision 1Evidence pendingDissent retained 0
A teaching model with outcomes you choose. These checks illustrate the rules; they do not run real agents or tests. Acceptance requires passing evidence for the current revision.
What happened
The rules are the point.
Generation, review, and acceptance are separate responsibilities. Dissent reopens the proposal and stays in the record. A failed check requires a revision. Old evidence cannot certify new work. Passing a check makes acceptance possible; it does not make the decision for you.
Try accepting a result, then introducing a new objection. The system should be able to change its mind.